Today, Ofcom has published its assessment of how age assurance can support the UK Government’s planned ban on under-16s using social media, identifying four methods capable of meeting its ‘highly effective’ standard. The regulator has also published a separate report examining how app stores could play a greater role in protecting children online.
Verifymy was pleased to contribute to Ofcom’s rapid assessment, which provides greater clarity for platforms preparing for the proposed restrictions. The findings also highlight the challenges of reliably verifying age at 16, with the focus now shifting to how these measures can be implemented effectively while balancing robust protection for children with accessible ways for legitimate users to prove their age.
Four methods for age assurance at 16
Ofcom has identified four methods currently capable of meeting its ‘highly effective’ standard for determining whether someone is aged 16 or over:
- Photo ID matching: Checking an identity document, such as a passport or driving licence, against a live image of the user.
- Digital ID services: Allowing users to prove their age digitally, potentially without repeatedly presenting physical documents.
- Banking-based checks: Using age information held by a financial institution, with the user’s consent.
- Facial age estimation: Analysing facial features to estimate a user’s age.
The assessment recognises that fewer methods can reliably establish whether someone is over 16 than over 18. Established approaches such as email and mobile-based age checks remain highly effective for adults under Ofcom’s existing guidance, but cannot be solely relied upon to distinguish between younger teenagers and those aged 16 or over.
This distinction matters for implementation. Email and mobile-based checks can allow platforms to establish that many existing adult users meet the age requirement using pre-authenticated information they already hold, without requiring additional user interaction. As these checks can happen seamlessly in the background, some adults may not need to complete an active age check when platforms already hold accurate and reliable information that establishes their age.
For teenagers, facial age estimation and document-based verification will play a more prominent role, alongside digital ID and banking checks.
The challenge of getting the 16-year threshold right
Age assurance at 16 presents a particular challenge because the consequences of an inaccurate result can work in both directions.
Facial age estimation can be accessible and convenient, but its margin of error means that platforms need to account for uncertainty around the threshold. Ofcom recommends a ‘challenge age’ approach, similar to Challenge 25 in retail, with additional verification used where a user’s estimated age does not provide sufficient confidence.
This creates an unavoidable trade-off. A threshold designed to prevent almost all under-16s from accessing a service may also mean that some legitimate 16- and 17-year-olds are asked to complete further checks.
Photo ID matching, digital ID and banking-based checks can help resolve these cases, but access to documentation remains an important consideration. Ofcom estimates that around 150,000 young people aged 16 and 17 in the UK have neither a passport nor a driving licence.
Ensuring that these users have accessible ways to demonstrate their age will be an important part of implementation.
Circumvention cannot be eliminated, but it can be reduced
Ofcom acknowledges that some children will find ways to bypass age checks. Its assessment identifies additional safeguards, including allowing users to report suspected underage accounts and using age inference signals to help identify people who may have circumvented an initial check.
It is positive to see the UK taking learnings from international approaches to age restrictions. Australia’s social media ban requires platforms to take ‘reasonable steps’ to prevent under-16s from holding accounts. The UK Government has said it intends to build on that experience by introducing more highly effective age assurance measures, with Ofcom’s assessment providing greater clarity on the methods that can meet this standard.
No approach will eliminate circumvention entirely, but detailed guidance can help platforms understand what effective implementation looks like and how different measures can work together to reduce the risk of underage access.
The longer-term impact matters, too. Beyond restricting access for existing teenage users, a significant opportunity lies in preventing younger children from entering these environments unrestricted, helping to change the point at which social media becomes a normal part of growing up.
Dame Melanie Dawes, Ofcom’s Chief Executive, highlighted this longer-term ambition in her remarks today, pointing to the potential for younger generations to enter secondary school without social media being an assumed part of everyday life.
This is an important distinction. The success of the ban should not be judged solely by whether every existing teenage user loses access, but also by whether it helps establish different social norms for younger generations. That is a longer-term cultural shift, not simply a question of whether an individual age check can be bypassed.
App stores have a role to play
Ofcom’s second report examines the role of app stores in children’s online experiences, recognising that they are an important gateway through which children discover, access and download apps.
The regulator found that app stores could do more to protect children through greater use of highly effective age assurance. However, age checks alone will not be sufficient: app stores also need reliable information about the suitability and risks of the apps they make available, alongside appropriate safeguards and parental controls.
Responsibility for complying with the Online Safety Act remains with regulated services. Nevertheless, a more coordinated approach across platforms, app stores and devices could provide an additional layer of protection.
Whether and how app stores are regulated remains a matter for the Government to consider.
Implementation will determine the impact
Ofcom’s assessment gives platforms greater clarity on the methods that can underpin age restrictions at 16. The next steps are for the Government to set out how the ban will work in practice, followed by Ofcom’s further guidance and preparation for enforcement.
Platforms should use the coming months to assess their existing user bases, establish appropriate age assurance processes and prepare clear routes for users who need to challenge an incorrect decision.
The challenge is to make these measures effective without creating unnecessary friction for legitimate users or excluding teenagers who cannot easily access conventional identity documents.
As the UK moves towards implementing the ban next year, the emphasis must remain on practical safeguards that work at scale. Age assurance is an essential part of that framework, but its success will depend on how well the technology, supporting processes and wider online ecosystem work together.
Ofcom has set out a credible starting point. The priority now is to translate that framework into meaningful, measurable improvements in children’s online safety.
Verifymy is ready to support platforms in implementing highly effective age assurance in line with Ofcom’s guidance. Get in touch to discuss how we can help.